As kids, we always assumed that the “Non-Toxic” claim on a can of Play-Doh was nothing but a dare. However, as seen in the video Edible Sweet Art, there are still grown adults who claim to have never tried to eat the ‘edible’ dough.

Watch these liars feign a surprised reaction, as they try to convince us that this is actually their first time. Or, perhaps eating it as a kid is just an unfortunate memory that they’ve suppressed.

It’s understandable, considering that Play-Doh does tastes like Poseidon’s butthole. Please watch…

[link, via Gizmodo]